Fishing Kayak Vs Paddle Board: Which is the Best Option for You?

Table of content

• Fishing Kayaks and Paddle Boards: The Basics
• Paddle Board v/s Fishing Kayak: Pros and Cons
• Detailed Comparison Between Fishing Kayaks and Paddleboards
• What to Look For When Buying a Stand Up Paddle Board?
• What Kind of Kayak is the Best for Fishing?  

Do you prefer fishing from the water rather than the conventional method of doing it from shore? Then, Fishing kayaks and paddleboards are two important watercraft you should be aware of. Both kayaks and paddleboards are excellent means of fishing from the water. However, there's always confusion when comparing these two to decide which is best.

In this article, we'll discuss the basics of fishing kayaks and paddleboards, their pros and cons,a detailed comparison between them, and more.

 This video is sourced from YouTube@PaddleTV

Fishing Kayaks and Paddle Boards: The Basics

A fishing kayak, as the name hints, is a type of kayak specifically designed for fishing purposes. They typically feature a broader framework to offer better casting and carting fish stability. These kayaks are constructed with anglers' comfort in mind and often include storage options to keep the fishing gear. There are different types of fishing kayaks, such as inflatable fishing kayaks, sit-in kayaks, sit-on-top kayaks, and so on. Each of these types offers specific advantages to suit your fishing style.

A fishing paddle board, sometimes also known as a Stand-Up Paddleboard, is a versatile watercraft that allows you to fish by standing or even kneeling on the top. It is a blend of kayak and surfboard. Often lightweight and smaller than kayaks, they're the perfect choice if you prefer a wider vantage point while fishing. Generally, paddle boards come in two varieties: hardboard and inflatable paddle boards. 

Below is a table that lists the significant features of paddle board vs kayak.

Paddle Board v/s Fishing Kayak: Pros and Cons

Detailed Comparison Between Fishing Kayaks and Paddleboards

• Stability 

In terms of stability, both kayaks and paddleboards provide a steady paddling surface that one can use easily without using much effort. Finding balance on an SUP could be a challenge at first, especially if you're trying it for the first time. However, once you get the knack of handling it, you may find fishing from a paddle board easy. That being said, a kayak could be a more stable option for several other reasons. For instance, when you are sitting, your center of gravity is lowered, which eventually improves the stability. Because of this, you have a lower chance of falling into the water. 

• Fishing 

If you plan to fish from a paddle board, remember that you have a significant visibility advantage as you'll be standing during the activity. You can even transform the board into an exceptionally sturdy fishing platform by attaching extra accessories such as a deck bag, rod holders, etc. 

The choice depends on your tastes. If you fish only for leisure, then you may better go with a kayak. 

• Storage 

In comparison to stand-up paddle boards, kayaks are larger and heavy. Hence, if you buy a fishing kayak, storing it is challenging, especially if you have a compact storage space at home. In such cases, an inflatable paddle board would be the best alternative. Kayaks are hefty, so even with their ample storage capacity, getting them to and from the water or into and out of storage every time you use them is quite an effort. 

Because of their compact design, stand-up paddle boards are easier to manage. Additionally, paddlers living in tiny spaces can easily store and display them on the rack. 

That said, inflatable kayak and paddle board models offer similar advantages, as they can be deflated and stored easily.     

• Gear Storage 

During your SUP or kayak fishing adventures, you might need to store equipment and other necessities. How many accessories you bring depends on the length of the trip. Day trips may not require a lot of equipment, and hence, either kayak or SUP board will work just fine. 

Stand-up paddle boards even include front and rear bungee tie-downs that let you carry a cooler box and a few bags. But this may not be sufficient during long trips. You must need a lot of gear for multi-day trips and long-distance paddling. Majority of kayaks include several on-board storage spaces, and this makes them a perfect choice for such trips. For example, sea kayaks include dry hatches, a larger cockpit, etc. This will just keep all your fishing gear safe.   

• Cost 

It's pretty hard to decide which is the best option when it comes to affordability. You’ll get both kayaks and paddleboards that fit your budget. There is something in every category for everyone, with prices ranging from a few hundred to several thousand dollars. 

• Performance 

The size of a kayak or paddle board determines how adaptable it is. Most river paddlers favor small, lightweight paddling watercraft as they are simpler to manage and shift. However, if you love to blend the speed element with the fishing activity, a kayak would be your best option. Sitting in a kayak reduces resistance and allows you to travel across the water more quickly. SUP requires you to stand on them, which results in a slower pace and greater resistance. 

• Weather conditions 

Sit-in kayaks may not be a great choice for fishing in the warm weather. They are designed with a cockpit in which you have to sit. This makes it difficult to move freely. Consider a situation for instance: You're planning to dive in for a brief refreshing swim, but it would be too much work to get out and back in the cockpit. In such cases, a paddle board will come in handy. On the contrary, if you're paddling in cold weather, consider using a kayak, as your whole body will be out while fishing on a paddleboard. 

• Fitness 

In terms of fitness, paddle boards are the best choice. These boards offer a low-impact full-body workout that perfectly tones your body. That being said, kayaking is also an additional means of exercising. Kayak paddling offers an individual exercise that targets your back, shoulder parts, chest, and abdomen. 

Fishing kayaks and paddle boards are also unavoidable elements in water sports activities. The nature of sport decides which is the best choice for that specific sport.

What to Look For When Buying a Stand Up Paddle Board?

• Shape:

Choosing the correct shape is the most crucial factor to consider when buying a paddleboard. If you're looking for a board for all-around use, prefer one with a rounded tail and nose.

• Type:

Though inflatable boards are more portable and simpler to store, hard boards are more stable. Likewise, soft top boards are the preferable option for novices, but epoxy boards feature a more conventional design and handle the water better than inflatables.

• Size:

Size is also an important element to consider as it determines how well you can paddle through different water bodies. Generally, a longer, broader board provides greater stability and storage options for fishing.

• Deck pad:

If you're into fishing in a river, get a paddle board deck pad that covers half or more of the front of the board to get that grip.

• Fins:

The most sensible paddle board option is the one with a single fin as it increases surface area without adding additional drag. You may find several varieties of fins including flexible fins that bounce off obstacles, and stiff fins are ideal for running downwind.

What Kind of Kayak is the Best for Fishing?  

Among the different types of kayaks, the sit-on-top model is arguably the most preferable one for fishing. These kayaks usually feature wide beams that provide excellent stability, making them simple to use and get in and out of. Additionally, the elevated position in your sit-on-top kayak offers good visibility for throwing. Below are some major deciding points that’ll help you choose the best kayak for fishing.

• First, decide whether you want an inflatable sit-on-top kayak or a conventional sit-in kayak. Inflatable kayaks are ideal for individuals who prefer little storage space.
• Choose between pedaling and paddling options. Opt for the paddling option if you enjoy the fun of working out while fishing.
• Consider the weight capacity of a kayak. Think about your weight and the amount of equipment you wish to keep on it while heading for fishing.
• How simple is it to lift and manage the kayak? This is also an important factor, as knowing the kayak's weight will help you decide whether you can handle it alone or need help.

Fishing kayaks and paddleboards have their own advantages and disadvantages. It's evident that both provide enjoyable and distinctive water experiences. Your fishing style, personal tastes, etc. determines whether you go with a kayak, paddleboard, or the hybrid version of both When making your choice, remember to take the important aspects into account such as the areas you plan to paddle, the things you like to do, and the way you want to feel the water.